White Wolf Community

Argue ferociously about Sidereal Martial Arts in this thread.

rated by 0 users
This post has 81 Replies | 3 Followers

Top 75 Contributor
Posts 975
Daredevil:

But, yes. Hopefully, in a year, when they start to release Exalted Revised (White Wolf never releases 3rd Editions, just "Revised"), this pointless Charm cap will be gone.


I would not bet on it. The people who are currently writing for the line (as far as I know) feel it is quite important, I think.
Top 200 Contributor
Posts 466
Here's the thing, many Sidereal fans like things the way they are.

The innability to make custom Charms being seen more as a 'feature' than a flaw, and their mastery of Martial Arts being seen as the tradeoff for it.

Hence the dislike over the dilution of that niche... And see the "Lunar SMA" thread for why Astrology does not compare favourably with Knacks for being the "special Sidereal thing".
I like the image of the Ebon Dragon tumbling down a set of stairs in Malfeas with a bucket on his foot and a swarm of angry bees around his head, shouting "God damn the Solar Exalted!" - Holden
Top 50 Contributor
Posts 1,727
Rebecca Borgstrom has suggested to make shattering ongoing sorcerous effects with SSP cost (Circle)Xps. So you can't just go casually dispelling solar sorcery spells, but if you need to, you can. And it's still just as easy to smash a spell that's casting.
Unfortunately, the best we had the opportunity to do was perform triage on the Deathlord Issue by way of firing gauze and surgical tools at it out of a bow from down the street. - Holden Shearer, about fixing the Deathlords' write up in GotMH
Top 500 Contributor
Male
Posts 292
Using EXP as an expended resource is a bad idea because mechanically, it really has no effect on NPC's, especially with the EXP debt mechanism already built into the game system.

Top 25 Contributor
Posts 2,116
Sojko:
Rebecca Borgstrom has suggested to make shattering ongoing sorcerous effects with SSP cost (Circle)Xps. So you can't just go casually dispelling solar sorcery spells, but if you need to, you can. And it's still just as easy to smash a spell that's casting.
I don't understand why Sidereals can't simply rely on Mending Warped Designs for long-term things.  They actually have a charm that, with enough organization and planning, can directly reverse the use of Rain of Doom on a city.  Nobody else has something that can do that so directly; combined with their perfects, I don't think they really need more tools for coping with SCS than that.
Top 75 Contributor
Male
Posts 1,110
Aquillion:
I don't understand why Sidereals can't simply rely on Mending Warped Designs for long-term things.  They actually have a charm that, with enough organization and planning, can directly reverse the use of Rain of Doom on a city.  Nobody else has something that can do that so directly; combined with their perfects, I don't think they really need more tools for coping with SCS than that.


True, and I absolutely love that charm and encourage its use in all things, though it should be noted that a single Sidereal can, by and large, only use it on trivial matters.  Repairing the area destroyed by Rain of Doom is likely to require ten or more Sidereals at once, and Total Annihilation should probably just be worked around.  While I'm wary of how capable it makes a Sidereal of opposing Solar Circle Sorcery effects (which are weak enough without SSP and anti-sorcery charms), I often consider just allowing a Sidereal to extend the damn roll indefinitely.  Seriously, it'd only take a few hours of that to repair an area melted by the acid rain, but it would also leave that Sidereal doing nothing but obviously re-arranging threads for hours.  Any nasty around can just walk up and kill him while he's working.
Where am I going? I don't know!
When will I get there?  I ain't certain!
What'll I do?  I ain't equipped to say!
Top 200 Contributor
Posts 454
Obsidian Shards:
Hence the dislike over the dilution of that niche... And see the "Lunar SMA" thread for why Astrology does not compare favourably with Knacks for being the "special Sidereal thing".

Some of us think it should, however.
Page 6 of 6 (82 items) « First ... < Previous 2 3 4 5 6 | RSS
Powered by Community Server (Non-Commercial Edition), by Telligent Systems