Sparketh:Or kill them all and make them vamps! Or kill them all and make them geists! Or have some True Fae drag them off to Arcadia and unite the group years later. Perhaps there was enough wolf blood (or even pieces) in those corpses to make them wolf blooded upon redemption. Shortly afterwards, they experience the first change. There are endless possibilities really. Talk to your group about what they want.
vhurka:Good answers, but not really what I was going for. Maybe I was unclear:I am not currently running a promethean game,and as such am nowhere near the point of needing to figure out "okay, what do I do with these guys?"Though that's also a legitimate concern, of course. I was just curious about what an NPC promethean would do and how they would react to becoming mortal. I can't imagine it would be easy to adapt to.
Innerlight:Actually a promethan who is redeemed would actually know what it means to be human because that was the point of his journey. He would have a good grasp of how human behavior and if he doesn't what the hell was he busting his ass trying to do. As far as his/her actual mindset it's up to you. Though they're not confused anymore.
vhurka:What happens to these guys after the pilgrimage is over?